Re: [BUG] 100% reproducible oops on ATAPI CD-ROM I/O error, 2.5.75

[Moritz Muehlenhoff]

In stuga.ml.linux.kernel, you wrote:
> I added this as a comment to bugme.osdl.org bug 878, but here's a
> cleaned-up version of the reproduction instructions:
> 
> 5. readcd dev=/dev/hdc f=/dev/null
> (readcd chokes near the end of the CD, tries reading again, and oopses
> the kernel)

With kernel 2.5.75-bk3 it doesn't oops neither on my CD-RW, nor on
my CD-ROM. I guess that's related to ChangeSet@1.486 from Jens Axboe
   [PATCH] Fix IDE-CD command failure re-play
   
Does anyone have an explanation why cdrecord fails to write the last
sector properly? Is this a kernel issue or a bug in cdrecord?
I'm using cdrtools 2.01a15.