Re: [BK PATCHES] add ata scsi driver

[James Bottomley]

On Mon, 2003-05-26 at 14:18, Jens Axboe wrote:
> > 1. Unified SG segment allocation.  The SCSI layer currently has a
> > mempool implementation to cope with this, is there a reason it can't
> > become block generic?
> 
> Of course that is doable, when I killed scsi_dma.c it was just a direct
> replacement. Given that IDE had no such dynamic sg list allocation
> requirements, it stayed in SCSI. Overdesign is never good :)

I agree with the sentiment.  I just don't think variable size SG tables
will remain the exclusive province of SCSI forever.

> > b. the host adapter is out of resources for *all* its devices.  Block
> > all device queues until we free some resources (again, usually a
> > returning command).
> 
> This is harder, because it involves more than one specific queue.

Yes, this is our nastycase, especially for locking and ref
counting...you didn't say I only had to hand off the easy problems,
though...

Hotpluggin has to have some awareness of this locality too.  Even for
IDE, hot unplug a card and you can lose two devices per cable.

> > 5. There needs to be some amalgam of the SCSI code for dynamic tag
> > command queue depth handling.
> 
> Again, block layer queueing was designed for what I needed (ide tcq) and
> no overdesign was attempted. If you describe what you need, I'd be very
> happy to oblige and add those bits. Some decent depth change handling, I
> presume?

Pretty much yes, now.  We lost all of our memory allocation nightmare
problems when we moved away from fixed command queues per device to lazy
command allocation using slabs.

James