Re: i/o stalls on 2.4.14-pre3 with ext3

[Linus Torvalds]

In article <[e-mail]>,
Andrew Morton  <[e-mail]> wrote:
>
>ext3's problem is that it is unable to react to VM pressure 
>for metadata (buffercache) pages.  Once upon a time it did
>do this, but we backed it out because it involved mauling
>core kernel code.  So at present we only react to VM pressure
>for data pages.

Note that the new VM has some support in place for the low-level
filesystem reacting to VM pressure. In particular, one thing the fs can
do is to look at the PG_launder bit (for pages) and PG_launder bit (for
buffers), to figure out if the IO is due to memory pressure.

A "sync" will not have the launder bit set, while something started due
to VM pressure will have the bits set.

>Then again, maybe something got broken in the buffer writeout
>code or something.

There are two really silly request bugs in 2.4.14-pre3. I'd suggest
trying pre5 which cleans up other things too, but even more notably
should fix the request queue thinkos.

		Linus