Re: How does "alias ethX drivername" in modules.conf work?

[Andrzej Krzysztofowicz]

"Riley Williams wrote:"
>  > If I build a system with several identical (other than MAC)
>  > FooCorp PCI ethernics, they will number up in order of ascending
>  > MAC address.
>  >
>  > I take the same system, replace the FooCorp cards with BarInc
>  > NICs, they will number up in reverse MAC address.
>  >
>  > Replace them instead with Baz Systems NICs, and I get them in
>  > bus scan order (at which point I'm dependent on the firmware
>  > version of my PCI bridge too!).
>  >
>  > And if I elect to use Frob Networking NICs, I instead get them
>  > in the *random* order that their oncard processors won the race
>  > to power up.
>  >
>  > Gods and demons help me if I try putting several of all four
>  > brands in one box, or the firmware on my NICs or in my PCI
>  > bridges changes!
> 
> I dealt with this problem in a previous email, but will repeat it for
> your benefit. The ONLY provisos I will use are the following two:
> 
>  1. All ethernet interfaces in your machine have distinct MAC's.
> 
>  2. If the firmware in your NIC's changes, the MAC's do not.
> 
> Providing both of these are met, the enclosed BASH SHELL SCRIPT
> implements the `ifconfig` command with the port name replaced by its
> MAC address.

1. NFS-root needs to have RARP/NFS servers on eth0.
   How can you deal with it if you have two boards supported by a single
   driver and, unfortunately, the one you need is detected as eth1 ?
   Assume that you cannot switch them as they use different media type...

> With this change, it doesn't actually matter what port name a
> particular interface is given, because ALL of the other network config
> tools refer to the interface by its assigned IP address, not its port
> name. As a result, if its port name changes between boots, the routing
> automatically changes with it.

2. ipfwadm / ipchains / iptables may use interface names,
3. dhcpd may need interface names to be provided,
4. you may want to pass an interface name argument to tcpdump...

In 2.2+ you can deal with 2.-4. changing interface names using ip from
iproute2. But I doubt whether ifconfig based scripts would work properly
then. And problem 1. is still valid ...

-- 
=======================================================================
  Andrzej M. Krzysztofowicz               [e-mail]
  phone [phone]
Faculty of Applied Phys. & Math.,   Technical University of Gdansk