Re: [PATCH] rw_semaphores, optimisations try #3

Andrea Arcangeli (andrea@suse.de)
Mon, 23 Apr 2001 23:34:35 +0200


--a8Wt8u1KmwUX3Y2C
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline

On Mon, Apr 23, 2001 at 09:35:34PM +0100, D . W . Howells wrote:
> This patch (made against linux-2.4.4-pre6) makes a number of changes to the
> rwsem implementation:
>
> (1) Everything in try #2
>
> plus
>
> (2) Changes proposed by Linus for the generic semaphore code.
>
> (3) Ideas from Andrea and how he implemented his semaphores.

I benchmarked try3 on top of pre6 and I get this:

----------------------------------------------
RWSEM_GENERIC_SPINLOCK y in rwsem-2.4.4-pre6 + your latest #try3

rw

reads taken: 5842496
writes taken: 3016649
reads taken: 5823381
writes taken: 3006773

r1

reads taken: 13309316
reads taken: 13311722

r2

reads taken: 5010534
reads taken: 5023185

ro

reads taken: 3850228
reads taken: 3845954

w1

writes taken: 13012701
writes taken: 13021716

wo

writes taken: 1825789
writes taken: 1802560

----------------------------------------------
RWSEM_XCHGADD y in rwsem-2.4.4-pre6 + your latest #try3

rw

reads taken: 5789542
writes taken: 2989478
reads taken: 5801777
writes taken: 2995669

r1

reads taken: 16922653
reads taken: 16946132

r2

reads taken: 5650211
reads taken: 5647272

ro

reads taken: 4956250
reads taken: 4959828

w1

writes taken: 15431139
writes taken: 15439790

wo

writes taken: 813756
writes taken: 816005

graph updated attached. so in short my fast path is still quite faster (r1/w1),
slow path is comparable now (I still win in all tests but wo which is probably
the less interesting one in real life [write contention]). I still have room to
improve the wo test [write contention] by spending more icache btw but it
probably doesn't worth.

Andrea

--a8Wt8u1KmwUX3Y2C
Content-Type: image/png
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="rwsem2.png"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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--a8Wt8u1KmwUX3Y2C--
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/