RE: fyi megaraid problems

[Margulies, Adam]

This message is in MIME format. Since your mail reader does not understand
this format, some or all of this message may not be legible.

------_=_NextPart_001_01C08636.A39C40BA
Content-Type: text/plain;
	charset="iso-8859-1"

I've compiled the 2.2.18 and 2.4.0 kernels with the latest megaraid driver
(1.14b)
and they work well. You should also upgrade your firmware to L148 (bios
3.11).
I think the firmware revision depends on which model card you have, I have
the
1600 Elite.

This is on a Penguin Relion 120, 2 CPUs, PIII, 1G RAM.
Two 35G drives configured as one logical drive.

I will say that I did float around for a while and found quite a few
different
versions of the driver (1.07b,1.13s,1b08b,1.13s0,1.14b, I have them all!)
before Venkatesh Ramamurthy at AMI helped me figure this all out. (thanks
Venkatesh!)

Venkatesh posted the 1.14b driver to this list a week or two ago, and you
can
get the firmware upgrade from ami.com.

-----Original Message-----
From: Heitzso [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Wednesday, January 24, 2001 11:51 AM
To: '[e-mail]'
Subject: fyi megaraid problems

don't know if this has been covered/studied

datapoints I've run across re the megaraid
(scsi raid driver, american megatrends)

box: Dell PowerEdge 2300, 2 cpus, 1G RAM

hard drive setup as single drive via raid
controller

RH6.1, compiled 2.2.13, megaraid works!

RH7.0 install/upgrade breaks on megaraid
then, after forcing RH7.0 upgrade by hand 
 (completely snuffed up with all updates as of jan 23 am ...)
RH7.0 kernel (out of the rpm box 686 smp) breaks on megaraid
RH7.0 2.2.16 kernel source from rpm 
 compiled using 2.2.13 .config file
 and make oldconfig generates kernel that
 breaks on megaraid (used RH provided
 scripts to compile with kgcc)
2.2.18 kernel (kernel.org) compiled with gcc on RH7.0
 breaks on megaraid during boot

BUT! 2.4.1pre10 (kernel.org), compiled with gcc on RH7.0
 the megaraid driver works again!

I was surprised that even 2.2.18 breaks
then 2.4.1pre10 works, given RH's alliance
with Dell.

I compiled a 2.4.0 and set it up in
lilo.conf but haven't tried booting to it.

If it's useful to anyone, now that I have
a good booting kernel I could recompile the
old 2.2.13 setup and see whether the problem
is due to a bad compiler env in RH7.0 or
due to a bad megaraid module (i.e. if kernel
that works fine now compiled under 6.1 
breaks when recompiled under 7.0 then bug
is in the RH7.0 compiler env; else bug is
in megaraid shipped with 2.2.16, 2.2.18)

Let me know if someone needs a datapoint.

Heitzso
[e-mail]