Title of the paper _____________________________________________


Reviewer ______________________________________________



Overall Score (1-5)
clear reject // weak reject // weak accept // clear accept // best paper nomination


Relevance: What is the relevance of this paper to Complex Systems? (1-5) 


Significance: Are the results of practical significance? Can the described method be reproduced?
              Are the results of theoretical interest? (1-5) 


Technical soundness: Is the paper technically sound? Are the concepts correct and accurate?
              Are all claims reasoned well? Is the experimental setup reasonable? Are the
              results interpreted carefully? (1-5) 


References: Is the work being put into context well? Has all relevant work been cited? (1-5) 


Clarity: Is the paper clearly written? Is it well-organized? Is it understandable? (1-5)  



Brief summary and general comments
_______________________________________________________________________________________________








________________________________________________________________________________________________



Detailed comments
_______________________________________________________________________________________________








________________________________________________________________________________________________